Top 5 4 star in New York City

124 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016, United States

“Stayed with a friend for a two-week vacation, in a room with two double beds. The room was clean, in good shape, and surprisingly spacious (closet space is limited though). The staff are excellent, and housekeeping is amazingly prompt. The hotel is also in a great location, within walking distance of much of midtown Manhattan and with easy access to the 6 train. City noise was noticeable but not ridiculous. Our room faced 27th St., so an interior room would probably be quieter. Overall this is a fantastic hotel! I thoroughly enjoyed the stay and would definitely return.”

101 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

“I feel like the reviews do not give this hotel justice. We booked it as a fairly cheap option for our 8 night stay over New Years, and looking at the reviews and pictures our expectations were quite low. However the hotel had great service …”

15 Gold St, New York, NY 10038, United States

“Great location in the financial district. Lot's of subway access. The rooms are beautifully decorated, as is the hotel lobby. But, there is one BIG drawback...it's SO NOISY, even by NYC standards. I swear the windows are paper thin and you can hear cars endlessly driving over a loose manhole on the neighboring street. Constant, maddening, rattling. Also, the room doors do not shut smoothly, so you'll hear every guest on the floor slamming their door at all hours. If you are sensitive to noise in the slightest, this is not the hotel for you. Even if you're not, bring ear plugs!”

134 4th Ave, New York, NY 10003, United States

“We had SUCH a wonderful stay with our one-year-old here over the holidays! We booked a junior suite which was a stunning corner room with floor to ceiling windows and great views - it was the perfect size for a family of three. The staff was wonderful, very attentive and so kind to our baby, even playing with her in the lobby and offering stickers. Our room was stocked with a crib, extra blankets and pillows, baby soap, a fridge, and more! We were very comfortable here for nearly a week and could have stayed longer. Also loved the thoughtful touches like morning coffee and evening prosecco in the lobby! If you know NYC you already know how phenomenal this location is - so much is walkable and then the subway is right there if you want to explore even farther. We will absolutely be back!”

30 W 31st St, New York, NY 10001, United States

“Perfect stay at Hyatt Herald Square We loved our stay at this location. TAYLOR at check in was especially helpful and friendly. She even had a tray of fruit and a Happy Anniversary card for us in our room when we checked in. She allowed us to leave our luggage since we had an early arrival, and texted us as soon as our room was ready. Room was super clean, and we had a great view of the Empire State Building.”

118 E 40th St, New York, NY 10016, United States

“Clean 5 Stars - traveling with a young child. A historic hotel with a distinctive artist touch. The staff is extremely friendly and helpful. The location cannot be beaten, I can’t highlight this enough. You can visit every major attraction in NYC by just catching a train at Grand Central. We’ve spent 7 nights in one of the larger rooms and it’s perfect for a small family with children. I want to thank the staff at the Renwick for a great stay. We truly enjoyed our vacation here”

120 E 39th St, New York, NY 10016, United States

“Second stay here in three months, and it just a pleasant as the first. Cordial staff and quick service (thanks Miranda and Jesus!) Rooms are spacious, though a little worn, and very quiet. The first stay was right next to the elevator, but we didn't hear it or any noise at night -- from the street or hall -- for that matter. The curtains block out the light pretty well. Had to play around with the air conditioning/heating to get the right room temperature, and that wasn't a real issue. Plenty of amenities nearby, including a deli with water/drinks etc. Down the street are a number of excellent restaurants at all price points, and the front desk offered many suggestions. Fabulous and safe location in Murray Hill, close to theaters, transport and shopping.”

60 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022, United States

“This hotel was gorgeous and the quality/service was incredible! My wife and I came to NYC for a family celebration and spent our weekend here. The rooms were spacious and the beds were quite comfy. All staff members we interacted with were friendly and helpful. They provided us with delicious restaurant recommendations (highly recommend the Monkey Bar attached to the hotel if you can get a reservation) and set up reservations for when we arrived. They were also more than accommodating with our arrival and departure schedules when plans shifted around some. I should also note that the whole hotel is furnished with beautiful French antiques and florals which really add to the charm of the experience. The location of the hotel was also wonderful. So many shops! There are also lots of delicious restaurants only a few blocks away, and if you are up for a little longer walk, you can easily get to Time Square and Broadway The hotel also offers a complementary breakfast which later turns into a snack/coffee/tea room. We found the breakfast was more than substantial with yogurts, pastries, and some other options. It was great when we were in a hurry one morning, but also great when we were having a relaxing morning with tea/coffee before heading out for brunch. It was an amazing weekend and I will absolutely be coming back next time I am in NYC.”

305 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036, United States

“This was my first stay at the Civilian Hotel. My son and I spent an extra long weekend taking in some Broadway shows. We are so happy we chose this place! The location could not be better - very walkable to theaters and Times Square, yet …”

517 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States

“Room: Pros:Nice room, clean enough, nice bathroom. Larger and more modern than I was seeing with other similarly priced properties. Comfortable bed Cons: The heat was unbearable to sleep in. Set it at 65 and never got below 74 and felt more like 84. Maintenance came up to duct tape the hot air vent. Very uncomfortable and hard to sleep. Service: Pros: Hotel front desk staff was nice. No lobby. And they answered the direct line when we had questions upon arrival Cons: Tried to use Cognac restaurant for breakfast. Waited 20 minutes at our table with no service even for water so left. Host said nothing. $25/day breakfast credit kind of useless Location: All pros here. Just outside the hustle and bustle of the main attractions - Times Square, Rockefeller etc... but in a nice city block with fewer retail establishments.”

201 E 24th St, New York, NY 10010, United States

“No one around to help. No climate control. Inner rooms had no view, and absolutely no wifi. Noisy air system, heat on crazy high in winter, had to open a window. No one was around to help. Emailed but didn’t hear back until after 4 pm. By then I chose to leave and go to Best Western Empire and it was 110% better experience. Go to Freehand, go to Moxy, go anywhere but here.”

140 W 24th St, New York, NY 10011, United States

“Great location, everything was close by. Amazing view on the Empire State Building. Bed was very comfortable and the shower was really good! You could hear everything through the door though. You have to wait quite a long time for the elevator and often they are packed full. Breakfast was ok - packed during rush hour and not great selection. Lobby was always full of people waiting for something and some were sleeping on the floor. Overall good experience but will not stay here again. Good price for what you get but it’s not a 4-star hotel as advertised.”

235 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, United States

“Great hotel. Roomy rooms. Massive beds! Posh washer dryer toilets with heated seats. TV, fridge and a kettle (some complimentary teas and coffees would have been nice but no biggie). The location is excellent. Close enough to many of the NY attractions that are within walking distance (Times Square, Empire State, Rockerfella, Broadway, and Central Park a bit further up. The hotel has a lovely Japanese restaurant, we got a 10% discount for being guests at the hotel. Really great food and friendly service. Overall really pleased with whole experience”

30 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, United States

“Derrick and Zay, the two hotel desk clerks were so pleasant. The room was nice and clean but wish it were a little more spacious. The location was perfect for a first time visit to New York. Everything was within walking distance. Thank you for helping make our stay a great one.”