Top 5 American Restaurant in Lancaster County

11 results match your filters

Sort by:

Filter by:

Neighbourhood

See all

Categories

See all

Customer rating

Distance

Sort Sort
Filter Filter
Stubby's Bar And Grille
4.5
( 8 reviews ) $$

254 E Frederick St, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States

“Great menu, food portions, atmosphere, and service. It’s been a good 10 years since I’ve been here, and it’s only changed for the better. St patty’s day is as good post Covid as it ever was. Free breakfast at 7am sharp. Food and drink specials, Irish dancers. Top notch. The bangers and mash was the best I’ve ever had, with that splash of French onion 😍. Stubby, you are a legend.”

Kountry Korner Drive-in
4.5
( 8 reviews )
Open until 08:00 PM

610 PA-897, Reinholds, PA 17569, United States

“Great little place and their menu is HUGE with a number of varieties sure to appease the pickiest of eaters! Their soft serve ice cream is delicious and offers many flavors! Hard to find different flavors of soft serve in this area so this is a real treat.”

Lancaster Brewing Company
4.4
( 8 reviews ) $$

302 N Plum St, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States

“My wife and I ate here over the weekend. It was our first time, but we would love to come back. The food was really wonderful. The effort given throughout the meal preparation is fantastic. The quality of meats, baked goods, and side dishes was out of this world. I was especially happy and surprised by the quality of coffee. Absolutely wonderful and from a local coffee supplier. The staff was well trained and attentive. The dining area was very clean. There was another guest at a nearby table that seemed to have numerous health concerns and I saw a server being very attentive and helpful to them. My only negative is that the parking lot is pretty tight. Keep up the good work LBC!”

Divine Swine
4.4
( 8 reviews ) $$

2684 Lebanon Rd, Manheim, PA 17545, United States

“I've been here twice now and both times were very good. Excellent BBQ. The first time I just tried the pulled pork with a side of mac n cheese and cole slaw. The sides are very good and the pulled pork had a good smoked flavor and wasn't too dry. I added the sweet Kansas city sauce which is my favorite so far. On my second visit I ordered the ribs. OOOOoooo wee!!! Probably my 2nd best ribs I've ever had. Tender and tasty. They fall off the bone so beautifully.”

Frogtown Cafe
4.6
( 16 reviews )

684 Marticville Rd, Pequea, PA 17565, United States

“Inconsistent with the hours, multiple times I have shown up at 7:45 or 8pm on a Wednesday or Thursday and the doors are locked. Two times now this week I tried. I love this place but it’s very frustrating as I drive from Lancaster to come visit because google says they are open until 10pm and then I get here and the doors are locked.”

Captain Gus's Steak Shop
4.5
( 10 reviews )
Closed until 07:30 AM

600 W Orange St, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States

“First, the staff is incredibly friendly and nice. I had to go in and pay for seven different orders separately and they didn’t even bat an eye. The food was also ready in the exact time they said it would be. The cheesesteak is one of the best I’ve had in Lancaster, and I’m not even a marinara on a cheesesteak kind of guy. The meat was super flavorful and it had plenty of cheese. So many places really lack in the cheese department, but not Gus’s. The fries were a bit soggy, but let’s face it, I wasn’t there for the fries. Overall, this place is better than half the “talked about” places in Philly.”

Conestoga Wagon Restaurant
4.6
( 10 reviews )

2961 Main St, Conestoga, PA 17516, United States

“A nice little spot in southern Lancaster County. It’s attached to a gas station and there is a little convenience store inside with the restaurant. The decor looks like you’re in a western movie. The menu is extensive and there is bound to be something for everyone. Prices are good and the portions will set you up for at least two meals. Worth a stop if you’re in the area. It’s right down the road from Pine View Dairy and Cherry Hill Orchards.”

Reflections Restaurant
4.3
( 8 reviews ) $$
Closed until 12:00 PM

1390 E Oregon Rd, Leola, PA 17540, United States

“First time at Reflections. The atmosphere was very nice. Reminded me of a place where we are originally from. Very comfy and looked like maybe people were regulars. Our server was so nice!! She took great care of us. Our food was really good, too! I had the surf and turf as well as French onion soup. My only complaint would've been my steak. Seemed grainy?? It was fine though. We will definitely go back again!!”

Stoll And Wolfe Distillery
4.8
( 8 reviews )
Closed until 02:00 PM

35 N Cedar St rear, Lititz, PA 17543, United States

“We took a quick day trip to Litiz from West Chester and highly recommend Stoll and Wolfe Distillery. Susie was an incredible mixologist. Had fabulous skills, great recommendations, and we were fortunate enough for there to be a lull when we arrived so she was able to talk cocktail history with us. The menu she has crafted was carefully thought through, unique, and delicious. One of the absolute best whiskey sours I’ve ever had. 10/10 would recommend - well worth the hour drive!”

Square Mile Public House
4.1
( 8 reviews ) $$

14 W Main St #1632, Mountville, PA 17554, United States

“Great local place, that seems to constantly upgrade! Food is fantastic and they have a new pizza oven that puts out some really good pizza with all sorts of combinations of toppings. Have been here many times and will continue to visit.”

River Trail Brewing
4.4
( 8 reviews ) $$

40 E Front St, Marietta, PA 17547, United States

“Out on our adventure we visited this place and they had a monster BLT that was amazing, adding with delicious fries seasoned to perfection. My wife got the mahi-mahi sandwich which was also very delicious. The staff was friendly and great! The stout beer is worth trying even on a warm day. Because it was a warm day and they even gave our dog an amazing beer..... Well ok, they gave him a bowl of water for which he was very thankful. We will definitely be back to visit.”

Top 5 American Restaurant in Lancaster County

In the heart of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania with 11 spots, you'll find amazing American Restaurant, holding an impressive reviews with almost 100 reviews from people worldwide.