Top 5 Bagel shop in New Jersey

80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head, NJ 08742, United States

“A charming local establishment, offering a delightful array of baked goods and coffee that generally impress. Their selection of cookies, a major highlight, ranges from classic to inventive. While most of their cookies receive high marks for flavor and texture, those adorned with frosting tend to fall short, lacking the same appeal as their unfrosted counterparts. The bakery also serves a nice breakfast selection, which holds its own in terms of quality and taste. The options are varied enough to suit different preferences, and each baked good is prepared with care, ensuring a satisfying morning meal. Delectable danishes and turnovers to name a few. However, the service at Mueller's Bakery, particularly when ordering, could use some improvement. The interactions tend to be somewhat dry and lack the warmth you might expect in a cozy bakery setting. This aspect, while not detrimental to the overall experience, does leave room for enhancement. In summary, Mueller's Bakery is a solid choice for anyone seeking quality baked goods and a pleasant breakfast option. Their coffee pairs wonderfully with their selection of treats, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors. With a bit more attention to the customer service experience, this bakery could truly excel.”

21 NJ-31, Pennington, NJ 08534, United States

“A relaxing ambiance with plenty of seating. They have unique bagel flavors and cream cheese styles, such a Birthday Cake, which was surprisingly tasty. Additionally, in assessing their plain bagel in comparison to other bagel shops in the area, they score quite well. However, the service is quite slow after placing your order, particularly for a bagel place, so I’d recommend calling ahead.”

212 Pacific Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, United States

“Walked in to a huge crowd of people, knew it had to be good. I watched for a minute as they pumped out order after order and decided to give out a try. They did not disappoint. Service was very friendly, food was great, literally perfect, and because they felt like they took a long time, they gave me free drinks. I thought they did great considering how busy it was and was in no rush. We enjoyed our food at the breakfast counter. Can't wait to come back.”

1021 US-202, Branchburg, NJ 08876, United States

“Stopped here on a trip for a quick bite. although it was super busy they moved the line and didn’t make any mistakes on our rather large order. They had lots to chose from and we all enjoyed our sandwiches. Reasonable prices.”

660 Plainsboro Rd, Plainsboro Township, NJ 08536, United States

“One of my all time favorite places! Been going here 15 years and the food it's always excellent, if you're looking for a classic NJ bagel place with excellent sandwiches look no further! The staff treats you like family, 10/10”

456 Elizabeth Ave, Somerset, NJ 08873, United States

“As a bagel and cream cheese guy, I would say 5 stars. Bagels are big and excellent, the best in the area.. Service is great. Sometimes if you go there during peak hours you may wait, but that is due to the popularity of the place. The woman who is usually up front is a pretty, pleasant, dynamo who almost always keeps her cool. Tried other bagel shops recommended to me and I still think this is the best. I am giving it 4 stars rather than 5 because when I had an egg sandwich there I think it was lacking a bit. It had the opposite problem from the usual, as it had too much bacon and not enough egg. Another very minor issue is that the spreads are not marked, so you have to ask the staff what each one is. Minor quibble, but I feel it needs to be pointed out. Short version, this it the best bagel shop in the area. Recommend it with minimal reservations.”

329 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307, United States

“I was up visiting family for the holidays and i was really craving a pork roll, egg and cheese on an egg bagel, Since FL doesn't come close to a real Jersey bagel, this did not disappoint! It was delicious! I'll be back next year for sure!”

1090 St Georges Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065, United States

“THIRD time ordering a pork roll EGG and cheese, third time getting just pork roll and cheese. How you can consistently leave out the egg on and EGG breakfast sandwich I do not understand it’s the main ingredient. We try to call to let them know this keeps happening and are immediately put on hold for 10+ minutes and no one ever picks up the line. We tried for about a half hour before giving up.”

134 Baldwin Rd, Parsippany, NJ 07054, United States

“Service is terrible. The women behind the counter act like you’re bothering them if you place an order. One guy was running around putting together an order and the other guy looked like he was going to fall asleep. The bagel was not great for the price.”

482 Boulevard, Kenilworth, NJ 07033, United States

“A family night out for some Italian food. We had a drink at the bar and the drinks were very good with a nice pour. Dinner selections were ample between appetizers, pasta, entrees and specials. You will need reservations and parking was on the street with free parking after 6pm, otherwise it is 2 hour metered parking. Food was very good”

1225 State Rd, Princeton, NJ 08540, United States

“Pretty mediocre, even for central Jersey bagel standards. Way overpriced too. What should have been a $4 bagel for the taste/quality ended up being a $7 bagel.”

88 E Main St, Mendham Township, NJ 07945, United States

“These bagels are truly one of a kind! The taste of just a simple toasted bagel with butter is to die for. The service is great and they are all so smiley and truly look like they love there job. The atmosphere looks like a traditional bagel store just feel a lot of extra love.”

78 Lakeview Ave, Clifton, NJ 07011, United States

“Just had another really great sandwich from Lakeview deli. Turkey and cheddar on a roll, with lettuce tomato onion mayo mustard salt and pepper. Less than 10 bucks for a fatty sandwich!! I’ve never been disappointed here. I also really love the Cuban sandwich here.”