Top 5 Hotel in Suffolk County

1 Circle Rd, Stony Brook, NY 11794, United States

“My family has stayed at this hotel before, and again this time it met our needs perfectly. Rooms are basic, but nice and clean. Location is perfect- close to shopping, restaurants, quaint Northshore towns AND our family!”

400 S Jamesport Ave, Riverhead, NY 11947, United States

“Had my wedding here in October and it was amazing. The staff was super helpful and very professional. The grounds are beautiful and the suite is a photographer’s dream for photos. Erin, the bridal attendant, was THE BEST! She was there whenever I needed her but never in the way and knew what I needed before I even knew myself! The food was amazing and guests are still saying how they have never had such delicious food at a wedding. The chef was accommodating to our taste preferences and guests’ allergies. My husband and I are gardeners and the venue even developed a signature cocktail using fruit my husband and I grew ourselves. Breakfast the next day did not disappoint and the guest rooms are super cozy and comfortable. 100000% recommend. It can be hard to get an appointment for a tour but just keep trying till you get through!”

101 Boulevard E, Yaphank, NY 11980, United States

“Had a bad experience while enjoying our stay talking with family received a call from the desk stating they had numerous complaints from multiple floors of the noise we were making. Actually watching the All Star game and talking at 1030pm. We needed to be quiet although we paid for our rooms just like everyone else. Lady across the hall came out she was sick with covid and could we not go back and forth between the rooms we occupied . The lovey shaggy rag front desk Kelly assumed we were in the wrong without listening that it was 2 family members on separate floors making the accusation. Never in all the hotels I've been in has anything like this happened. We have had partys before in a room. Never have I been worried about the noise anyone else is making. Let's learn to mind our own business. Moral of the story is don't stay here you may get arrested or thrown out because your neighbors money is better than yours. Never more offended.”

236 Edgemere St, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Montauk in the winter is almost just as lovely. The lobby beautifully decorated for Christmas with Christmas music playing was just wonderful! Monte’s was well priced with good food. The shuttle service was a great added surprise so both my husband and I could enjoy drinks with dinner. We had a fabulous stay and will be back!”

2038 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States

“The room, lobby and hallway was nice and clean. The heater system didn’t work. It seems like they have some automatic energy saver set up. The system would start, would not blow hot air and then shut off. It’s February and very cold in the room. The pressure in the shower wasn’t strong enough. Bed were comfy. There was not enough staff to bring up blankets. I had to go fetch them myself in the middle of the night. Would I stay here again. I’d probably search other places before I choose this place.”

7 Court House Dr, Central Islip, NY 11722, United States

“Everyone that works in the hotel is amazing. I stayed this weekend there for my son's tournament. The lady that serves the breakfast is rude. Something must of happen this pass Sunday because breakfast was horrible. IT Was 9am no oatmeal scrabbled eggs,fruit or muffins. I took my son to Burger King to get breakfast not something that I wanted to do since breakfast was included. Other than that the Staff is amazing 👏”

1830 West Main Street, NY-25, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States

“The hotel staff were excellent and the room was pretty decent. There wasn't a fan in the bathroom but overall the room was good. The blackout shades worked well and the outside area was very inviting. The beds and pillows were very comfortable and we enjoyed our stay.”

2000 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville, NY 11738, United States

“Staff was very friendly and accommodating. Room was pristine. Continental breakfast was great. Location was perfect many restaurants within short walking distance. Will definitely book again.”

2 Sawgrass Dr, Bellport, NY 11713, United States

“Very unprofessional staff and General Manger Dominique LaRosa. Kids screaming running around all times during the night. The hot water in the hotel took 20 minutes to get hot. The front desk said they know of the problem. They don't warn guests before issuing them a room. Front desk agent thought that it was funny smiling and laughing while I'm telling him my issues. Telling me that it only takes 4 minutes for the water to get hot. So again you know there's a issue don't warn guests about it. Dominique didn't do about it. No money off or anything claiming she couldn't do anything because I booked via third party. Room 302 dirty. They didn' patch work on ceiling in the room and only painted the affected area because you can clearly see that there's two different types of paint on the ceiling. Couch stained and dirty. Hotel definitely needs to learn attention to detail and customer service because they lacking in those areas. DON'T STAY HERE”

680 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, United States

“Hotel is very nice. Clean and bright. Front lobby is very attractive. Plenty of tables to sit at. Breakfast was good. Front staff friendly. Our room was updated. It was very clean. Bathroom was a good size. Beds not so comfortable. Definitely will stay here again if in the area.”

2050 Express Dr S, Hauppauge, NY 11788, United States

“Positives first: The pillows were great!! The sheets were good. The room was neat and clean. The rest of the bed linens looked and felt cheap. The mattress was adequate but not exactly comfortable. Overall, the bed was adequate but disappointing. The door to my room was literally bent at the bottom. The door needed a little extra pressure from the inside to close and a sustained shove to engage the deadbolt. (photo & video) I booked the room both last-minute and late at night and this may have been a factor in the preparation of my room. The air smelled stale. Low temps hit 32° that night and I had to manually turn on the heat. The towels were thin. In the shower were 2 bottles of conditioner, 1 bottle of shampoo, and no soap/body wash. (photo) I notified the front desk at checkout and some comment or question about the ability to call and have it changed was made by the clerk. I don't think it was meant to be rude and I wasn't offended, but it indicates real ignorance and a failure to process feedback from this guest. Scrambled eggs & plain omelettes were served together at the same breakfast buffet. Literally the same food in different shapes. Why? (photo) Both turkey and pork sausage were also served and I respect legitimate and common dietary reasons to offer an alternative to pork sausage. As of 01/08/2024, a printed notice regarding roof work references a 2-3 wk project expected to begin 11/01/2023 and was still posted. (photo) The project is still in progress.”

143 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937, United States

“I love this place for dinner, the food is truly amazing and the service is always great…truly a pleasure to dine here!”

259 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946, United States

“Everything was perfect, rooms are very clean and property was awesome. Reasonably priced for the area and in a great location. Only complaint is that the rooms were very humid. I know it was humid outside but it seems like the AC in the rooms made it even worse.”

428 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States

“Great hotel to stay in! The front desk people were very welcoming and polite. The room was very spacious, clean, and up to date. The breakfast in the morning was great where the receptionist gave their guests special attention as well. The restaurant food was very good as well. Highly recommend staying here specially if you are visiting the wineries since its only 20min drive from here.”

1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932, United States

“I cannot recommend this incredibly special gem enough!!! Topping Rose House is one in a million. Every single detail from the historic architecture, to the luxury and cozy hotel, to the exquisitely delicious farm-to-table menu, to the very warm, welcoming and amazing wait staff - is simply the best….. I cannot wait to return and experience the magic of this beautiful season - and every season - here at Topping Rose House!”

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, United States

“Despite not making reservations in July, I was seated very quickly. Next time ill make sure to make reservations so I can sit on the rooftop. The sunset was amazing that day and the view from the restaurant was perfect. Everything was so fresh, I can't stop thinking about the branzino it was so fresh and delicious. The portions are small for the hefty price they charge especially for the pasta I ordered, nonetheless, everything was really good.”

626 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Picture it 1980’s the Catskills - an intimate place where families can go back to every year and create life long memories. Now fast forward to modern day out east Montauk, that same feel of family togetherness - beach, pool and s’more making - all at Hero Beach!”

61475 N Rd, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

“Great place for families with young children. They hosted a movie night on a projector and a pizza night where a local brick oven pizzeria truck came to the property and made a ton of different pies. The beach area is pretty narrow and rocky but a great place to watch sunset!! There was also morning yoga on the lawn. Will return!”

44 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Location couldn’t be better. Just a block walking from the beach and right in downtown Montauk. This boutique hotel I have been staying at the past 2 years and absolutely love it. The rooms are always clean and the parachute sheets add just a special touch that makes the bed so cozy to sleep in on summer and winter nights. The staff is incredibly kind, attentive and knowledgeable. The restaurant across the street also serves the best breakfast. I will always stay at Daunts.”

1399 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947, United States

“this is honestly such a nice spot for the price. the bed was comfortable. the area was nice. staff were accommodating and pleasant. i would absolutely stay here again. the only thing for me, which doesn’t change my star rating, is the small size of the bathroom. i’m a bigger guy so that was a bit tough but i made it work and it doesn’t take away from the rest of the establishment”