Top 5 Inn in Suffolk County

1830 West Main Street, NY-25, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States

“The hotel staff were excellent and the room was pretty decent. There wasn't a fan in the bathroom but overall the room was good. The blackout shades worked well and the outside area was very inviting. The beds and pillows were very comfortable and we enjoyed our stay.”

143 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937, United States

“I love this place for dinner, the food is truly amazing and the service is always great…truly a pleasure to dine here!”

2166 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930, United States

“Extremely difficult to get hold of this resort via any channel. I had a question about checking in late and called at least three times and messaged without getting any feedback. I took my chance and went there and as I started getting automated notification of check in process looked like I could get in late. I wish they had answered me and stress me given they are so far into long Island to find out something you wanted is not available or possible. Their communication was very well organized after that and was able to find my room and get in. The room is just as pictured and perfect. The room has heating and cooling which is perfect. The view is marvelous and the sound of the ocean outside is just majestic. The hotel is few steps from the sandy beach which is again a great plus. I really enjoyed my stay here and will definitely return.”

44 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Location couldn’t be better. Just a block walking from the beach and right in downtown Montauk. This boutique hotel I have been staying at the past 2 years and absolutely love it. The rooms are always clean and the parachute sheets add just a special touch that makes the bed so cozy to sleep in on summer and winter nights. The staff is incredibly kind, attentive and knowledgeable. The restaurant across the street also serves the best breakfast. I will always stay at Daunts.”

1399 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947, United States

“this is honestly such a nice spot for the price. the bed was comfortable. the area was nice. staff were accommodating and pleasant. i would absolutely stay here again. the only thing for me, which doesn’t change my star rating, is the small size of the bathroom. i’m a bigger guy so that was a bit tough but i made it work and it doesn’t take away from the rest of the establishment”

300 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY 11968, United States

“I planned on staying one night but ended up staying an additional night. I really liked this place and the staff working here were very kind and helpful. The room was clean and comfortable and parking was easy. I would like to come back in the summer to use the pool. Bbqs are available on the patio as well and there is a large green lawn area. It’s a smaller property but I appreciated that. A quick drive to the beach and town and during the summer you could easily ride a bike to the beach.”

5720 Rte 25A, BAITING HOLLO, NY 11933, United States

“I had my wedding this past weekend on the East Wind property. I stayed in the hotel the next before and night of my wedding. When I returned home after, I noticed that my Airpod's were missing. They were stolen out of my hotel room and I was able to track them to an address that I do not recognize. The only people that had access to my room besides myself and my husband was the hotel staff. When I called to speak to the manager the day that I noticed they were missing and no one was there so they told me that someone would call me first thing in the morning. I had to call at almost 11am today to finally speak to someone. The general manager told me that there was nothing she could do until she spoke to her insurance company because there is no employee there living at that address. She told me she would call me within the hour after speaking to her insurance company. She told me to file a police report but I explained to her that I cannot because I live in a different state. All I wanted was to be reimbursed for the $240 I had to pay to get new airpods after having mine stolen from my hotel room. After 4 hours I had still not heard anything so I had to call back. She told me that there is nothing they could do after speaking to the insurance company and I needed to file a police report. I again explained to her that I cannot do that because I live out of state and I had just spent ALOT of money to have the best day of my life there and I had property of mine stolen from me and there is nothing they are willing to do to help me. So if you are considering having you wedding or any events there, do not stay at the hotel!!!!!!”

23 Centershore Rd, Centerport, NY 11721, United States

“This review is specifically for James who works at the front desk - he made our stay here last weekend extremely worthwhile. Provided the best service and even read us some poems he wrote. Hotel itself was quite old but comfortable to stay, it is one of the only hotels in the area. If we return, it would only be because of James!”