Top 5 Italian Restaurant in Wisconsin

N72W13350 Lund Lane Corner of W. Good Hope Rd and, W Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051, United States

“Food was pretty good....heavy on the grease though. Atmosphere was wonderful and customer service was perfect. I suggest Ally's Bristol invest in better silverware. It is unpleasant to eat a lovely meal with poor silverware.”

W61N305 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012, United States

“I have two gluten free kiddos and they went above and beyond in service. There was an innocent mix up in our order and they went above and beyond to fix it and make sure we had the correct food. I so appreciate the attention and care to this. Great job. I feel very comfortable and safe eating with my two gluten free kiddos here. Kudos. Will eat here again.”

124 Ash St, Baraboo, WI 53913, United States

“AMAZING!!!! We’re from out of state and wanted to try some of the local food. Found this place and seen some pictures of the pizza and had to try. Ordered the gem city supreme and was blown away. The large was around $34 with tax. The amount of pizza you get for that is unreal. The pizza was amazing. The crust was super crispy. The sauce was very flavorful. It was extremely cheesy and delicious. I have payed way more for a lot less pizza. The only thing about this pizza I would have changed is I would have let it cook a few more minutes. Most of the peppers and onions on top were still crunchy and a little under cooked but other than that hands down best pizza I’ve ever had. I just wish I wasn’t 4 states away.”

3927 75th St, Kenosha, WI 53142, United States

“This place is nothing short of amazing. We took a chance tonight and visited for our first time for my birthday. We love German food and usually frequent Mader’s in Milwaukee, this place is SO much better. The food, the atmosphere, the prices, the service, everything. Our server Avanti was extremely sweet, and all of the staff were so attentive. Every few minutes someone visited the table to make sure we didn’t need refills, to take plates, etc. You can tell this is a family run establishment, the staff were nice to each other in passing, saying “I appreciate you”/“thank you”/etc. It was such a nice environment. The free parking lot is a plus, and the prices for the portion sizes and food quality are great!! We ordered one appetizer and they brought out a bunch of extra goodies that were on the house! Since it was my birthday, they also brought out a dessert with a candle and sang happy birthday. We plan to come back, this place is such a hidden gem in Kenosha ❤️ thank you for such great service tonight!”

1101 Main St, Stevens Point, WI 54481, United States

“Wonderful food, great service. Everything was fresh & plentiful. Good cheese curds. Cold salad, hot soup, thick stringy cheese, nice sauce. Excellent Italian chicken, Lasagna & Sausage link. Pizza fills the box, thin crust, cheesy & lots of toppings. Very pleasant experience!”

422 S Pier Dr, Sheboygan, WI 53081, United States

“an authentic Italian food tasting experience 🇮🇹 is a place for elites, exquisite wines and flavors. on the shores of the lake in a privileged place, 💯% recommended. To delight and enjoy a pleasant time. Sybarite”

W2701 4th St, Fond du Lac, WI 54937, United States

“Great place. Visiting from out of town and traveling with our two dogs. Needed a pet friendly place for dinner, and they have an outdoor patio. This place was amazing. Great location. Great atmosphere. Amazing staff. Delicious food. Wide variety of options and spectacular desserts. Will be back for sure. Update: We just came back again, and it was spectacular. We ordered the daily specials and tried a new dessert. Prices are great and you never leave hungry. Highly recommend”

5825 Tower Ave, Superior, WI 54880, United States

“My bf loves their pizza but not from this area anymore. The breadsticks were as dry as it comes, and instead of giving a full bowl of chilli they gave me a literal cup size amount, and pizza was burnt.”

459 E Pleasant St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

“It just doesn’t get better than this honestly. This place deserves all the accolades it has received. Truly a great environment, the staff is top notch, the menu is unique and challenging and exciting. Loved every bite - hardest part honestly is figuring out what to actually order. Highly recommend the kitchen counter experience to watch the chefs work their culinary experience. It felt like we were the only ones there from the way they treated us, keeping an eye on every empty plate or glass, and looking for ways to make sure every dish is enjoyed at maximum (a chef gave us an extra plate of tortillas when they noticed I ran out halfway through my dish, for instance). Will definitely be going back for another meal in the future.”

1307 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

“Made a reservation for 9pm for a party of 4. Got the fried brussels and fried calamari for appetizers. They were so amazing and definitely recommend getting the fried Brussels. For our entrees, we got the duck carbonara, piccante, pesto, alfredo, and pomodoro. They were all cooked perfectly and they performed every recipe to perfection. The portion sizes were very large too, I had about 1/4 of the dish and I was stuffed! Took back home the rest of the pasta and ate it for numerous meals. The ambience was amazing and we were the last table seated. The only complaint was that it was very chilly in the restaurant, or at least where we were seated.”

741 N Milwaukee St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

“We’ve been here 2x in the last 2 weeks. Low lit so the pics aren’t great but the food is all amazing. Valet and street parking available (free after 6p I think too). Make reservations, even to eat at the bar - they are on opentable. We’ve had excellent soups both times! Service is friendly and attentive. Food and drinks are quick. Tiramisu is very tasty. Pasta dishes wonderful. Nice decor. Modern Italian for sure. Nom nom. Will be back.”

5844 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53213, United States

“So, just to explain my individual ratings...4 stars for the food because we absolutely loved & enjoyed the pizza we ordered; however, the garlic bread wasn't the best. It had a delightful crunch, but it seemed more like a buttered loaf than garlic bread that we're used to having. First visit, and it was an adorable/quaint spot to enjoy a meal for Valentine's. Our server was amazing, don'tthink we got her name initially but....she was polite, kind, smiling, and she seemed overall happy to be there. And she checked in on us to make sure we were doing okay.”

8390 Market St, Middleton, WI 53562, United States

“If you're looking for steak, pasta, and other hearty food, Johnny's is the way to go! Firstly, the service was snappy and attentive. Jackie was our waitress, and she did a great job making sure our table was taken care of. The restaurant has a distinct atmosphere to it - memorabilia of Frank Sinatra and The Rat Pack line the walls, giving the restaurant a sort of relaxed but classy feel to it. And of course, the food was great! My steak paired nicely with the cream sauce, and the garlic mashed potatoes were delicious! Well done!”

2414 S St Clair St, Milwaukee, WI 53207, United States

“Our dinners were amazing! I had the goulash-so tender and delicious! My friends had roast duck, burek, and sarma. All meals looked wonderful and my friends said everything was perfect. Be sure to get reservations so you are not disappointed because I understand this restaurant is very busy every night.”

2915 East Ave S, La Crosse, WI 54601, United States

“It's been a while so I went back to try new foods. I got the gyros and chicken/bacon wrap. Gyros was very small and didn't have much in it. It did taste good, but very limited on what it has. The chicken/bacon wrap was pretty good and moist. Average size wrap. Not too big, but not too small. The chicken wings were amazing as always. Big sized wings and it's my favorite.”

314 Main St, Racine, WI 53403, United States

“Excellent food and service”

1821 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan, WI 53081, United States

“Exceptional pizza place! The combination of fresh, quality ingredients, a perfectly crispy crust, and a rich, savory sauce makes every bite a delight. The friendly and attentive staff create a warm, inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just craving a great meal, this place is a must-visit. It's a culinary gem that consistently delivers top-notch, mouthwatering pizzas. Don't miss out on the opportunity to savor some of the best pizza in town!”

7616 W State St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213, United States

“We were lucky enough to have a perfect summer evening on La Terrazzo amongst their beautiful flower garden. The evening felt just like dining in Italy especially with the price fix menu featuring a four course dinner of Napoletana items. Every item we chose was simply amazing! Pasta was cooked to perfection. My lasagne tasted just like my mother in law's lasagne and she was from the Campania region! Delizia al Limone and the Torta di Cioccolato Amaro were a perfect ending to an amazing dinner and when they found out we were celebrating our anniversary our waiter brought us each a glass of proscecco to celebrate. We will definitely be back to celebrate special occasions here again!”

10627 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States

“Make sure you have reservations. Got there earlier and had a drink at the bar while we waited. Wife absolutely loved the blueberry lemon drop. We ordered the baby clams for an app. They were cooked in a garlic butter sauce. Crusted Parm Halibut and the seafood pasta. Very good!”

W61N480 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012, United States

“What a great evening! Delicious soup of the day- smoked tomato basil and appetizer of Rosemary sourdough focaccia with whipped lemon ricotta and salsa verde. Entrees of driftless gnocchetti with goat cheese & sage (pasta made in house) and chicken parm were fantastic. Really unique ice cream flavors including pumpkin, sage chocolate chip, banana bourbon and some others. The sage chocolate chip was SO good.”