Top 5 Italian Restaurant in Westchester County

23 Gray Oaks Ave, Yonkers, NY 10710, United States

“It was Thursday evening after work and we didn't have reservations and we was 2 seated immediately in the main dining room. Automatically I suggested the Lobster Ravioli w/ Shrimp in creamy lobster sauce. And Chicken parmigiana with pasta to split between us. And my business partner noticed The Avocado fries. Yes we certainly busted down our meal topped off with 2 Arnold Palmers Sweet lemonade mixed with unsweetened ice tea a perfect tasting blended drink. So yes we will be back for this in the cut spot.”

113 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, United States

“For the serious pizza lovers! They have pizza like everywhere else as cheese, buffalo,margarita etc but you should try the rest…they have amazing flavors I never seen before . The crust so yummy! The ricotta what they use, it drives me crazy! Daily soups ,least 5 -6 you can choose from! Pizza place very busy hard to find a table just be patient, you will see worth for the wait! Very friendly people who works so hard the front and back in the kitchen, to serves the best quality pizza on your and mine table! Sorry I couldn’t wait first we took the bites after I did the pictures..”

35 Abendroth Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573, United States

“The pizza here in Port Chester and in Stamford is the best thin crust pizza you will find. Service is great at both locations. The Port Chester location is large and there is plenty of room at their large bar and dining room. Get the cherry peppers with sausage. Amazing!”

15 S Central Ave, Elmsford, NY 10523, United States

“We passed by this restaurant today because of business. What I want to tell you is that this restaurant is really great! Although we looked for the door of the parking lot for minutes. when we sat down to taste these delicious food and wine, we found that it was worth the trip here, and the service was also very good. His name is Claudio If we have a chance, we will definitely come again, so I highly recommend it!”

5714 Albany Post Rd, Cortlandt, NY 10567, United States

“We picked up dinner for a small family gathering. The honey salmon that my sister in-law ordered was dry, the 2 orders of side fries tasted old and very salty. The chocolate cheesecake had freezer burn ! The only thing that was decent were the two pasta orders and the beet salad. Very disappointing since I’ve been living here 23 years and finally decided to try this restaurant! Now I know!”

97 Lake Ave, Tuckahoe, NY 10707, United States

“The staff is so welcoming to every person. The atmosphere is authentic Italian. They can add, or change anything to any meal you order if needed wheather for dietary restrictions or allergies. The food is cooked to perfection, from appetizers to main course, to dessert. Fried calamari is crispy with the perfect marinara sauce. Pasta is perfectly al dente. Meats were flavorful, falling off the bone and perfectly cooked. Scallops and shrimp were soft and not overcooked. We could have kept eating but it was so filling. Now I understand why people go back every week. They make you feel like you're family in their home.”

3436 Lexington Ave, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547, United States

“Love the new Augies Prime Italian spin! I’ve always loved the restaurant, so this new addition is even better. They still have all the popular steaks and my favorite shrimp cocktail. As an Italian food lover, the home made pasta additions makes the place even better. It’s still the same great staff and fun ambiance. Make sure not to forget to order the zeppoles for desert!!!”

683 Yonkers Ave, Yonkers, NY 10704, United States

“The pizza was wonderful. The service was fast. Would def return if in the area. Was a nice little pizza shop. It was empty when we walked in and within minutes the place was packed. I had the pizza with the cherry peppers and sweet chili sauce. It was so good. The crust is crunch and holds up. Was not soggy at all. I also had a slice of the bbq chicken. It was good but the spicy pizza was better for sure. Highly recommend stopping in for lunch if you are in the area.”

142 Fifth Ave, Village of Pelham, NY 10803, United States

“This charmingly beautiful romantic steakhouse will serve you a delicious dinner that will make you feel like you’re on a special date. The menu includes an amazing selection and delicious desserts that will also make you want more. Staff are welcoming and friendly. The real bonus here is that you can choose delicious food at a reasonable price compared to other restaurants. A great place.”

175 Katonah Ave, Katonah, NY 10536, United States

“Blue Dolphin in Katonah is a culinary gem that effortlessly earns its well-deserved five-star rating. Nestled in the unique setting of an old diner, this Italian haven, led by the charismatic Alfredo, offers an extraordinary dining experience that marries tradition with innovation. The Italian cuisine at Blue Dolphin is a culinary journey through authentic flavors and creative combinations. From classic favorites to inventive creations, each dish on the menu showcases a dedication to excellence. The standout recommendation of penne vodka with salmon perfectly encapsulates the culinary mastery found at Blue Dolphin—a delightful fusion of rich, creamy vodka sauce and expertly cooked salmon. Alfredo, the heart and soul of Blue Dolphin, adds a special touch to the dining experience. His passion for Italian cuisine and commitment to impeccable service create an atmosphere that goes beyond the ordinary. Whether guiding patrons through the menu or ensuring a warm and inviting ambiance, Alfredo’s presence enhances the overall charm of the restaurant. What sets Blue Dolphin apart is its unique setting in an old diner, adding character and charm to the dining experience. The fusion of old-school diner aesthetics with the refined flavors of Italian cuisine creates a truly memorable atmosphere. In conclusion, Blue Dolphin in Katonah is a hidden treasure, earning five stars for its exceptional Italian culinary magic. The combination of a delightful menu, the charismatic Alfredo, and the distinctive setting in an old diner makes it a must-visit. Highly recommended for those seeking an extraordinary dining experience that seamlessly blends tradition and innovation.”

886 Commerce St, Thornwood, NY 10594, United States

“Traveled from NYC for Cousin's party 80 ppl party on Saturday. Family style for apps, except for main course. Service attentive. All requests honored. I will be honest and say, I was quite surprised and didn't expect much from a Westchester Rest. But being a director in the food biz, I will say they did a great job! So keep doing what your doing. I always say if the food is so so but the service is excellent, than the place is worth another visit. But if food for a catered party is also good? that's hard to find then its a keeper! I will be back.”

228 S Highland Ave, Ossining, NY 10562, United States

“I'm not sure what has transpired but this place USED to be really good yet that's not the case anymore! Ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza, the crust was tough as well as chewy, it looked sloppy & tastes like it's sitting out all day... I'm sooo very disappointed SMDH!”

116 Katonah Ave, Katonah, NY 10536, United States

“A Quaint and Cozy Italian Restaurant with an scenic outdoor dining area. Among my favorite Italian Dining. A little on the pricier side but a pretty good kitchen. Wait Staff good and friendly. The Pork Chop with Vinegar Peppers was Amazing! Among the best Pork Chop I ever had. Even having it the next day, it remained tender. Definitely getting it again...Love those Garlic Bread!!”

52 Lake St, White Plains, NY 10603, United States

“Awesome spot with friendly service and good prices. The best part about the pizza was the crust in my opinion. It tastes almost like sourdough and is the perfect crunch on the outside and light and chewy on the inside. The Livia salad was also really impressive and I loved how many people came in happy to see the folks behind the counter during our quick visit. You can tell Nonna’s is a critical key to the community they serve.”

752 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, United States

“Greetings pizza fans. I did stop by this place twice. It is best to start with the food. I ordered a large cheese pie. Thankfully it was made to order fresh. It had a nice appearance and texture. Taste was good as well. The restaurant is cozy and clean. The only thing that needs improvement is to add more condiments that way each table has a set. As for the staff. They all seemed nice. The best part of my experience there was the manager Joe. He is a great guy. I would return just because of him. Would recommend stopping by and have some good pizza!”

487 Main St, Mt Kisco, NY 10549, United States

“I’ve been here many times & have enjoyed each time. However, this time warranted a review. I ordered the Tuna Tostada and WOW they were DELICIOUS, a very generous amount of Tuna. SO FRESH, every bite was perfect. As I sit here writing this I am thinking about placing another order 😅… okay yup just placed another order. To pair, I got a mezcal jalapeño margarita and it is amazing”

63 Main St, Irvington, NY 10533, United States

“Spectacular meal. Make sure you order at least one dish that includes artichokes. They are, without a doubt, the most amazing artichokes I've ever eaten. Of course, all of their dishes are incredible. I started with the Rucola, which was fresh, tasty, and of course, included the best artichokes of all time. I then had the Pollo Scarpariello. The sweet peppers and sausage, which were part of this masterpiece, made this one of the most memorable entrees I've ever eaten. I topped off the meal with a Tartufo. Not surprisingly, it was out of this world; the chocolate was not too sweet, and the whipped cream was creamy and delicious. In addition to the great food, the service was top notch. Our server was friendly, accomodating, and very efficient. Overall, a great dining experience. Oh, and don't forget the artichokes.”

425 King St, Chappaqua, NY 10514, United States

“Great red sauce/pizza joint. Simple dishes are spot on, pizza is good. Portions are for sharing, 1 dish can be shared for 2 people fairly easily. Headline prices may seem high, but one of the best value places for a family.”

2 Scarsdale Rd, Tuckahoe, NY 10707, United States

“Great Place to dine Wonferful staff and awesome food, everything is fresh and taste delightful, Martha the hostess was awesome very catering and wonderful personality. Great place for family, friends, and or an event. I would definitely come again. Me and my wife absolutely enjoyed this place. Our waiter was very friendly food came right out. Very pleasant and peaceful experience.”

67 Purchase St, Rye, NY 10580, United States

“Just moved to the area, and tried this new spot. I am a huge food critic and nothing ever “wows” me anymore and this place was a 10/10!!! Very fresh and healthy food options and a great pour of wine. Highly recommend if you’re in the area”