Top 5 Italian Restaurant in Brooklyn

32 Withers St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

“An amazing old school “red sauce” Italian spot. Order the garlic bread - it’s not on the menu. White table cloth and old school vibes. Cozy and they have all the traditional dishes. All the dishes were great! Will definitely be back”

853 Onderdonk Ave, Queens, NY 11385, United States

“My husband and I love coming here. We originally visited to try the burgers but enjoyed so many items on the menu. The drinks are great too. The service was very good, and the restaurant itself was beautiful. We visit at least once a month. Make sure to make a reservation because they book their tables fast!”

324 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

“Stone Park Cafe is the Barbie Movie of brunch spots. Everyone loves it and you want to be cool and counterculture and not like it, but with 5 star service (Molly), cozy clean decor and delicious food, you can’t help but follow the crowd and dawn your pink beach outfit and order the fish cakes. Stone Park Cafe lives up to the hype.”

140 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

“Great spot to sit down to eat & talk with friends. Music was pleasant. Staff was helpful in helping us make decisions. Food came out quickly and was delicious! Definitely had left overs, which they graciously packed for us. Also has a slice/ pizza counter at the front. Was a good, simple experience!”

701 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, United States

“One of my favorite restaurants in Brooklyn. I love their veg and meat options equally. The chicken is marinated so well and is rich with so much flavor. The Healthy One bowl is hearty, well portioned, and my favorite. My partner and I celebrated 1-year here. Sometimes the no contact, buzzer service has its glitches but I have noticed improvement over time. Come early on a Friday night for a seat! Great heat in the outdoor patio too for winter dining.”

905 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11218, United States

“Busy neighborhood spot. The service is great . The host is warm, pleasant, and very accommodating . The service was also on point . Ordered a Manhattan. It definitely was nothing short of spot on and a perfect start to the meal. Meatballs were good . I really enjoyed the scoop of ricotta that tops the dish. The vodka pie didn't disappoint. The sauce was nice . Really appreciated the service .”

72 Hudson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

“The food was delicious, the staff super nice and friendly. All the dishes we had was amazing and the balance of taste of food was perfect.The octopus was (I can’t explain it) FABULOUS, chicken was delicious as well. I’m not a chocolate fan …”

788A Union St, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

“Had a great brunch! Super reasonable pricing which included an entree and 1.5 hours of unlimited drinks that were not too sugary. I had the gnocchi which was a huge portion, and our server was attentive and great. Will be back!”

348 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

“My husband took me on a date to a fancy Italian restaurant. The food was exquisite. The beet salad, the califlower salad is definitely to try for. Especially when you have a great appetite and if you are on a healthy diet. The next was the pasta. The pasta i had was great. Seasoned well. All made from scratch. You can see the chefs preparing it. Amazing to see hard work and even better when you taste it. We even had the pork chop. It was delicious. Just melted in your mouth. Afterwards, we ordered the desert. The honeycomb was nice and sweet and the Ice-cream just melted in your mouth. The apricot cake was good too. The service was wonderful. The waiters really took care of you and gave you exactly what you need. Friendly and kind. You can see they love working here and greeting everyone they meet. The chef and the sou chefs are wonderful too. Overall it was a wonderful experience and I would definitely comeback here.”

522 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

“This is such a cute, quaint place. The atmosphere is lovely. I came here with my boyfriend. I got one of the specials, a pesto gnocchi dish topped with burrata. It was delicious; my boyfriend got a bass dish and I haven’t had a fish that good that wasn’t sushi. Very well seasoned. Had some nice wine as well. We tried almost every dessert and my absolute favorite was the flourless chocolate cake. It was so decadent and the cream topping helped balance it out perfectly. Service was also 10/10. Taylor made sure we enjoyed everything. We’ll definitely be coming back soon!”

316 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States

“We came here for NYE dinner and it was packed and had a great energy. Full tables inside and on the outdoor heated backyard. Service was great, especially given how busy they were and food and drinks did not take too long. The spicy rigatoni is actually very spicy, unlike similar dishes at other restaurants. Everyone enjoyed their meal!”

243 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, United States

“The food was very nice and the atmosphere is cozy. Our waitress was really attentive as well. Only negative point is that the dessert menu was a bit one sided. But I guess that changes since the menu had the date on it too.”

442 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

“Superb and excellent restaurant! Wonderful service and a tremendous menu with exciting meals. All fresh tasting and incredible offers. The owner, Francesco, really knows how to please his customers! I was there with guests from an after funeral mass meal, and I promised to return with my wife for a romantic dinner in the very near future.”

126 Union St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States

“Overall rating: 4.7 I just happened upon this place when I was in the neighborhood waiting to meet up with a friend. I had only a beer at the bar. But during that small amount of time, the hostess, bartender and staff were so friendly! It was much needed because I was having a rough day. I definitely want to come back and try the pasta if I’m ever in the area. Recommend giving it a try.”

82 Prospect St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

“This is great. It is a great place to stop and relax and enjoy a drink and some games. Upstairs, there is a bar and lots of fun games to play. I would definitely put this place on your list to visit while in the city. Great location between Brooklyn Bridge and Manhattan Bridge.”

490 Humboldt St, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

“I’m from out of town and was lucky enough to get an AirBnB down the street from this restaurant with an adjoining café. I got takeout last night - a delicious handmade tagliatelle pasta with mixed mushrooms and I went to the café this morning and had a great coffee and almond croissant.”

5 Greene Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

“Forma Pasta Factory deserves a solid 5 stars for its outstanding service, reasonable prices, and inviting ambiance. The staff went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience – friendly, quick, and attentive. The cozy atmosphere added a delightful touch to the meal, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed evening. And let's talk about their bolognese – it's an absolute game-changer! Flavorful, rich, and utterly satisfying, it's a must-try for any pasta lover. Forma Pasta Factory is a hidden gem that combines excellent service, affordability, and mouthwatering dishes. Highly recommended ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

1103 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

“The cacio y pepe, grilled octopus and mussels were amazing, so flavorful!! Loved esp the homemade bucatini pasta for the cacio y pepe and how it was cooked. Service was attentive and ambiance was great”

412a Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, United States

“This takeout option fails to impress. I am not sure how it is still around. Your response to my review was disappointing and unprofessional. My feedback was based on a genuine experience, not external biases or affiliations. Dismissing customer concerns does not bode well for your establishment's reputation. I suggest focusing on improving your service and product quality rather than questioning the legitimacy of customer feedback.”

323 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

“Returned here after not visiting in years. And omg, we were surprised at how good everything was. We ordered slices of pepperoni, regular cheese, mushroom and Pizza Bianca. All the pizza slices were delicious! There is a great deal of seating indoors for dining in. All the staff are friendly! Highlights: The Pizza Bianca is by far our favorite slice and best we have discovered in the area.”