Top 5 Italian Restaurant in Sarasota County

7 results match your filters

Sort by:

Filter by:

Categories

See all

Customer rating

Distance

Sort Sort
Filter Filter
Cafe Gabbiano
4.6
( 8 reviews ) $$

5104 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242, United States

“Absolute great experience. The food, especially the veal, was very, very good but the service from our server was exceptional. Alexandra(from Minnesota) made our visit an experience we will not forget. Her attention to detail was remarkable. She customized our dining experience. From extra touches on the before dinner drinks to customizing the menu to putting together an impromptu retirement dessert for my wife. I've eaten here many times before but this visit was an experience like no other due to her attention to detail.”

Cassariano Italian Eatery
4.5
( 8 reviews ) $$
Open until 09:00 PM

313 W Venice Ave, Venice, FL 34285, United States

“We live over 2 hours away, but have eaten here once before and I was excited to come back for my birthday dinner. I’m from upstate New York and Italian, so I’m picky with Italian joints. That speaks a lot. The food was great. Daniel our server was great. I got a free tiramisu for my birthday dessert, which was delicious. The only complaint I have is the guy that was at the hostess stand when we first got there, around 730. He was a bit rude and laughed in my face telling me they couldn’t seat us until after 9. The lady walked back up as we were about to leave (I assume the actual hostess?) and told us they’d text around 8 with a ready table. Sure enough, they did. A whole hour before the guy initially told us. Even if we had to wait until 9, it was his attitude that was the issue, not the wait. I think his snarky demeanor and the fact that he didn’t even have an accurate answer is enough reason not to have him greeting people. If we hadn’t been here before and I wasn’t set on wanting this for my birthday dinner, we would have been off put enough to go somewhere else just because of him. It’s not what you say, it’s how you say it.”

Jack Dusty
4.5
( 8 reviews )

1111 Ritz Carlton Dr, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States

“Went to stay at The Ritz while waiting for our new apartment to be ready. This is our new favorite place! Outside and inside dining with water views. Food is what you would expect. It was a busier night so we were seated with others but ended up having a great time. Drinks were fantastic.”

Cafe Barbosso
4.5
( 8 reviews ) $$

5501 Palmer Crossing Cir, Sarasota, FL 34233, United States

“This was my first time to this establishment I came there with zildjian catering for Christmas party even though it was a little late we had a wonderful time. The chef was amazing and had amazing tricks I loved watching him cook . I definitely will be returning with my family to show them the beautiful art and everything that was comes along with this building. Define the laughter and the beautiful scenery is definitely one night I will never forget”

Demetrio's Restaurant & Pizza
4.4
( 16 reviews )
Open until 08:00 PM

4410 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States

“The food was good. And for a Friday night, the service was okay as well. Parking was tight. I had to park in front of the gun store. I'd suggest checking for refills and paying at the table instead of standing in line at the front register. Just our luck, a large table got in line just before us! And they each had their own tab! But the orders were correct and came out in a timely manner. In my opinion, with other similar restaurants, I can get a little bit better quality dishes with more pampering during the dinner service.”

Marcello Ristorante
4.7
( 8 reviews )
Closed until 05:30 PM

4157 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States

“A wonderful Valentine's Day experience for sure!! My boyfriend surprised me, he did super well! Our first time here and we will definitely be back again soon! The experience is exclusive - in a small, private setting that definitely elevates the atmosphere. We truly enjoyed both of our entrées and appetizers - authentic Italian cuisine here! Will definitely book a reservation here again soon!”

Villani & Co Wellen Park Steak Seafood Raw Bar
4.5
( 16 reviews )

19790 Wellen Pk Blvd Suite 101, North Port, FL 34293, United States

“The summer deal with a bottle of wine is great, as well as the service. The portion size was a little larger than expected, and everything we had was good. While I have not had brunch here the place is packed when they do it. Great place to stop in for dinner, they also have a large raw bar.”

Top 5 Italian Restaurant in Sarasota County

In the heart of Sarasota County, Florida with 7 spots, you'll find amazing Italian Restaurant, holding an impressive reviews with almost 72 reviews from people worldwide.