Top 5 Pizza in Ohio

2643 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209, United States

“Update: we decided eat at the place on friday and man it was crazy busy. The definitely could use at least 2 more people, one server and someone else to take phone orders. We were there for over 2 hrs from waiting for a table to finishing and that phone did not stop ringing. Great to see they are pumping out that kinda business. The waitress was then only one with like 11 tables. She was doing the best she could though. Everything was good! This is an old school pizza joint serving up classic style pizza. They have a really thin crispy crust, so if thats your style, this is the place for you. They have a really nice balance of cheese and sauce, so that you can actually taste the sauce. All the ingredients are freshly sliced and not canned. They do use the sliced sausage, which i find weird. They don't have a ton of options for toppings which is another bummer, however they should have enough for most people. You guys should add a double crust to showcase your dough, I'd be interested in that! Thanks guys.”

2940 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH 44505, United States

“Pizza is so good! Generous with the toppings and the cheese, and the dough is excellent. We will be stopping in whenever we're making the trek from PA to MI. If you live anywhere in the area or happen to be driving through, make the stop. You will not regret it!”

2210 Beechmont Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45230, United States

“Been here 2ce and each time the pizza was SO GOOD!!! Dude working the counter was cool beans and the place was chill. Copped 2 slices and a pop left a $2 tip and the ticket was $15 ..decent for a couple killer slices 🤤”

2440 Maysville Pike, Zanesville, OH 43701, United States

“Went here on a recommendation; it's a cozy and cute place, decorated for the season and seems to have enough good help. It stayed consistently busy without feeling overwhelmingly loud inside either. The service is okay. I do appreciate thin crust pizza and the spaghetti meatball was cool (which makes the dish seem like it could be a vegetarian option). Then well..the salad comes as lettuce and cheese so if you want no cheese..you get a plate of lettuce? Lol! All in all, I would come back, thanks guys!”

783 S 2nd St, Coshocton, OH 43812, United States

“Love this place! Wish it was around when I was growing up. I remember we had Your Pizza there in the Plaza, which was similar, but this place.is better. I live in NC now, but every time.i come back home I come here for their delicious food. I really enjoy all the food on their buffet, specially their desert pizza. Always friendly staff that takes care of ya.”

3655 Cleveland Ave SW, Canton, OH 44707, United States

“First time in 30yrs going here. Pizza and Chicken were fantastic. Walked in and ordered to go, ready in 30 minutes!”

4114 Hamilton Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45223, United States

“It's one of my favorite hangout spots in Northside. People there are very supportive no matter who you are. They are making fantastic drinks and there food for a bar food is great! Warm recommendation on the pizza and the stromboli, all the ones that I had were phenomenal 😋”

37 E 4th St, Mansfield, OH 44902, United States

“While on a day trip to Mansfield to see the carousel we were hungry and wanted a bite to eat. We asked the guy running the carousel where was the best place to eat at in town and he recommended this place. We sat at the bar and ended up both getting the pierogi’s and kielbasa. The food was delicious! Definitely a must try for anyone who wants good cooking!!”

4416 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654, United States

“We got the pizza buffet. Good food and we were eating within 5 minutes after arriving. I think the buffet is only open Monday’s and weekends though.”

3936 E Galbraith Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45236, United States

“A nice Italian- American eat out. You all have to try this place for yourself to understand the simplicity of a place that has only been open for two years. The dining area is not for large parties. The picture of the inside was the aftermath of a party table of 8! The garlic rolls with garlic oil are the best out of all. I added to my order i had already placed, and the staff was so apologetic that it took extra time. Honest staff checking the order with the customers every time was great to hear. They did make a mistake on the calzon but remade it correctly before i even had my order. Instead of tossing the wrong in the trash, i was given a freebie. The real reason for a three star on the food rating just a little spices would go a long way! the pizza is just that school pizza. You either love it or you hate it. The spinach calzon could have used a mixing instead of being separated inside the calzon. Lastly, the chicken stromboli I ordered didn't have spinach and onions i requested. Overall, it's not a bad experience, but theirs room for improvement.”

154 E Main St, Batavia, OH 45103, United States

“When I walked in the guy said what can I do for you. So I would like a large steak hoagie pizza sauce, cheese, pickle, and no garlic butter. He said okay give me 10 minutes. I said okay. While I was standing there a waitress came up and asked about the remote for the TV she wanted to put it on the ball game. This man who took my order don't know his name yelled at her and said it's in my office I'm busy you're going to have to wait. I feel super bad for this poor waitress. And then when I got my order he said a large steak cookie with everything. I said everything? He said yes Pizza sauce, cheese, pickle, and onions. I said I did not say onions. He said I thought you did so he remade it. But obviously he doesn't listen to customers and he doesn't treat his employees with dignity and respect.”

929 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States

“I've had better frozen pizza. Looked like it was under a heat lamp for 1/2 hour. And tasted like it too. Was never like this when Paul owned it. If the pics look like it's dry and chewy, that's because it was.”

7144 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512, United States

“Very disappointed in the pizza they delivered. They aren’t cheap and the cheese was so limited! I called, the gentleman I spoke to was very kind. I offered to send photo, asked if it needed to be returned to get it replaced? Was told no, then they call back and say it does need to be outside to return for training purposes. My kids already began eating the decent pieces. The woman was just rude, the next pizza wasn’t much better. Really disappointed overall”

5634 Hall Rd, Galloway, OH 43119, United States

“Another great meal at Flyers. Service was great! Pizza, pretzel bites, and Saratoga chip...the best! Excellent thin crust pizza and pretzel bites with cheese. Saratoga chips a nice bonus!”

1739 Pearl Rd, Brunswick, OH 44212, United States

“My favorite non corporate style local pie maker. I've passed it for years and now realized, I've been missing out! The value is good, the pizza is solid. Handmade, and three styles of crust. Ya gotta love that! And that drive thru window rocks!”

13619 Detroit Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107, United States

“I got some sammies on a walk in order last month and I thought they were a little pricey; but when I wanted a pizza their prices looked like a good value. Then I found out why: their 18" pies measure 14" across. That's two strikes, and I'm not going for a whole inning when there are a million pizza joints in this town.”

2320 Tiffin Ave C, Findlay, OH 45840, United States

“Excellent pizza!! They were very busy but got our food in a very reasonable time. Had mini grinders that were delicious!! Best pizza in Findlay!!”

814 N Main St, North Canton, OH 44720, United States

“I have always went to donatos and loved their food. It's become my go to because they're cauliflower crust allows me to eat pizza on my celiac diet! You can't even tell the difference. So happy they got it!”

14 Maple St, North Lewisburg, OH 43060, United States

“My husband and I enjoy going and trying different pizza places around Ohio, we happened to be near the area and decided to stop by. The staff is very friendly, the service is great and the food is good. The pizza isn't the best I ever had but its definitely no where near the worst, the sauce has an ever so slightly sweet flavor to it (my husband being a sweet sauce lover had a harder time tasting the sweetness). I got the french bread pizza and my husband got a regular pizza. I tried both and the crust and bread were both good, nothing too fancy but better then some pizza places we've tried. They dont skimp on the toppings which is always a plus, my husbands bacon pizza had plenty of bacon sprinkled over top. They do have a good selection of drinks too from Pepsi products (bottle or cans) and even some iced tea and a few other drinks I can't remember. The building is a little older but they appear to be making updates (brand new lighting when we went in) and the tables were probably the cleanest I have seen in a restaurant in awhile. There are some arcade games, good for entertaining the kids, and their menu had other non pizza items as well. The pizza was a little on the expensive side for what it was but worth it to support a local business. You pay when you walk in and order then sit down so if you aren't one to normally carry cash you might want to make sure you have some change with you for a tip.”

5820 Douglas Rd, Toledo, OH 43613, United States

“My first time order from them.. customer service was amazing, food was delicious and for the price we got what we paid for even more! Highly recommend”