Top 5 Seafood in Suffolk County

28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States

“Nice little waterfront restaurant. Food was so good , I was not a fan of the style of the salmon but the texture was top quality. The dessert was very nice . Ice cream and almonds are a great combination. Will happily return.”

215 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787, United States

“H2O Seafood & Sushi is a culinary haven that had us grinning from ear to ear. From the first spoonful of their New England clam chowder, we knew we were in for a treat. Creamy, brimming with tender clams and savory applewood bacon, it was like a warm hug on a chilly evening. The duck tacos, the special of the day, were a revelation! Succulent duck meat danced inside crispy taco shells, a fusion of flavors that burst with every bite. The mango and cilantro toppings were the perfect partners, elevating this dish to culinary genius. And then there was the Starr Roll, a sushi creation that left us dazzled. It was a masterpiece, every bite a tantalizing journey of freshness. The creamy avocado, delicate salmon, and just-right tempura crunch with spicy mayo combined for a symphony of flavors that lingered long after the plate was cleared. The wasabi delivers a powerful, invigorating kick that elevates every bite to a flavor explosion! Our dining experience was made all the more exceptional by our server, Nick. His attentiveness and friendly demeanor added a personal touch that we greatly appreciated. H2O Seafood & Sushi is more than a restaurant; it's a celebration of flavors, an experience to remember. If you're in the mood for the best clam chowder, inventive specials, and sushi that wows, this is your place. A huge thank you to Nick and the entire team for an unforgettable evening!”

295 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946, United States

“Absolutely love this restaurant. Definitely one of my new favorites around the area. We went for my HB birthday with no reservation and they sat us down right away. We picked the corner on the outdoor area. The service was great and attentive, the food was delicious and pretty big portions. I definitely recommend the fried ravioli and the lobster pasta 🍝 drinks were also very good, actually I had one of the best margaritas here! Will definitely come back!”

541 E Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Selected this place for a birthday celebration mid-week and was amazed at the food and atmosphere. Had the special fish picante and it was cooked to perfection, plated beautifully, and the mixing of flavors was exceptional. The desert brownie was decently delicious! Already recommend to others.”

302 Middle Rd, Blue Point, NY 11715, United States

“I ordered the lobster roll, it was amazing! Loved the little diced cucumbers as an original touch! Would eat there again! 😁”

395 W Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, United States

“Title: A Seafood Lover's Paradise on Southside Fish and Clam! Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) I recently had the pleasure of dining at Southside, and I must say, it was a seafood extravaganza that left my taste buds dancing! This market and restaurant combo is a true gem for seafood enthusiasts, and I had the chance to savor some of their finest offerings. 1. Snow Crab Legs: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) The snow crab legs at Southside were nothing short of spectacular. They were perfectly cooked, incredibly tender, and seasoned just right. Each bite was a burst of sweet and briny flavor, making these crab legs an absolute must-try. 2. Lobster Roll: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) The lobster roll here was a work of art. The buttery, toasted roll was generously filled with succulent lobster meat, lightly dressed with a delicate sauce that allowed the lobster's natural sweetness to shine through. It was a heavenly indulgence. 3. Crispy Fries: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) Southside knows how to do fries justice. Their crispy fries were the perfect sidekick to the seafood delights. Golden, crispy on the outside, and tender on the inside, these fries were the ideal complement to the seafood dishes. 4. Fresh Clams: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) The fresh clams at Southside were a delightful surprise. Served steamed and seasoned to perfection, they were tender and flavorful. The natural brininess of the clams was balanced beautifully, making them a fantastic appetizer or side dish. 5. Oysters: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) The oysters were a true highlight of the meal. Served on a bed of ice, they were incredibly fresh and tasted like they were just plucked from the sea. They were briny, with a clean finish that left me craving for more. In addition to the outstanding food, Southside Fish and Clam's atmosphere was cozy, and the service was attentive. The staff was knowledgeable about the menu and happy to provide recommendations. If you're a seafood lover, Southside is a must-visit destination. With their top-notch snow crab legs, lobster rolls, crispy fries, fresh clams, and oysters, you're in for a seafood feast that's bound to leave a lasting impression. I can't wait to return for another unforgettable dining experience!”

99 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937, United States

“I love the most amazing scallop salad and the prime rib. They were not serving them this time I was there. I do not like the sweet sauce and char of the broiled ribeye. I appreciate them replacing it with fillet with less char and no sauce. It is much better and good service I love the dining room atmosphere Lack of quality desert variety makes me having no desert here”

551 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States

“We were looking for somewhere to eat dinner on Christmas Eve and came across Sumou. The rolls tasted fresh and were great quality. Inside was nicely dim and there's two dining areas, one for hibachi which we will be back for! Service was excellent, yelp check-ins even got me a free glass of house wine! The rolls were beautifully made, and came out super fast. Pricing was perfect for a sushi restaurant, $8-$18 a roll and the appetizers were in the same range.”

62300 Main Rd, Southold, NY 11971, United States

“A friend of ours invited us to A Lure Chowder House . He booked our table on their website and as a result didn’t get to have a choice of sitting outdoors or by a window. If that’s important to you, you must call the restaurant to make your reservation. While our friend was disappointed since he wanted his guests ( us) to have the perfect view, we loved our dinner as well as the service. And even sitting indoors, we still had a view and most importantly, everything we tasted was delicious!”

999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, United States

“Absolutely fantastic!! From start to finish a delightful meal. The special eggplant appetizer was so fresh and light! The lasagna was an explosion of flavors… not traditional but WOW!! The service was on point…Nicko is a wonderful server!”

210 Mill Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978, United States

“My wife and I had the most delicious dinner at Sushi 1!! It’s truly a hidden gem with the most accommodating staff. This was our first time here, but it definitely won’t be the last!! The sushi was extremely fresh and very flavorful. The ambience was low key and very serene! We look forward to our next visit!!”

2 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United States

“Super cute spot in sag harbor. Right across the street from a really nice view of the water. This place is a bit pricey but seems like they serve quality everything. We didn’t order much but def got a taste for what they are doing. Almost $100 for one bottle water, three drinks, mushroom toast (1 slice of bread) and guacamole with chips. My dad got freshly squeezed orange juice. I got a classic marg which was so perfectly made but the amount of ice was an overkill. My sister got a shot that’s supposed to bring people back from the dead based on its name but tasted more like an espresso martini. The serving size was super tiny but I guess some people might consider it cute. These things took away from the value for me. The price we actually paid VS What we were actually served. The mushroom toast was actually delicious but again for the price, there is little value because it’s so tiny and hardly filling for anyone. The guacamole and chips were the best value and the guac was perfectly seasoned. Overall, I would consider going back to try their dinner menu which was what caught my eye when I initially discovered this place online. The neighborhood is super cute and worth checking out. Cute, simple and does the job but definitely can get expensive.”

41 Smith St, Shelter Island, NY 11964, United States

“Delicious food. The best on the island. Everyone is very friendly. I can’t wait to come back🥰🥰 …”

364 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Great place for food and drinks and views of the water were spectacular. Great for boat lovers too as it is located at the marina. Tacos, nachos, beers, and margarita’s are a must. Outdoor and covered seating with an exceptional staff and bartenders. A must do if you’re in Montauk.”

65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“For anyone who’s left a poor review, it seems they are usually unhappy with long wait times or the price. It’s pretty simple, they don't take reservations, so plan accordingly. And inflation has made everything gone crazy. Is a lobster roll justifiable at $45? Likely not, but it was undeniably delicious and full of flavour. The food was tasty, fries were so great, the ambiance was pleasant, and the views added to the experience. While it might be considered expensive, it's worth remembering, this is the Hamptons – so if prices are an issue, go elsewhere. It's worth noting that it outshines two other lobster establishments nearby.”