Top 5 Tacos in Suffolk County

5507 Nesconset Hwy Suite #16, Mt Sinai, NY 11776, United States

“We have been here many times now and I have to say that tonight was the best yet! We shared the birria pizza and it was amazing. So filling and huge that we only had half of it. The salsa has a roasted garlic flavor to it that is just divine. The sweet plantains were made well done just like I asked for and they were delicious. The service is excellent and it’s just a cute little place for a quick meal.”

821 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743, United States

“The place I was looking to have for lunch was closed so I found this one on Google. I was ready to walk out after seeing how much it was for one taco. We decided to give this place a try and I really don't know why we didn't just go to burger king next door and spend less. I ended up getting a burrito which was priced at 11.50. I ended up paying $15 for it somehow. Is meat not included in a burrito?? My dad got two tacos and a soda. The total came out to $31. Insane. I asked for spicy salsa which I didn't taste. My dad's tacos were soaked and dripping in what I guess was the salsa. Tacos has one tortilla each so they were hard to eat on top of being soaked. Food was nothing special and the burrito was pretty small. Lacked flavor and the tortillas were pretty meh. Probably not made there. Really wish that other place was open. There are way better Mexican places around go to those before you waste money here.”

30 Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, United States

“I used to love the food here but today I found a large fly in my food. I just finished eating the rest of my food and now I’m disgusted. I don’t know how they could’ve missed this either. Unfortunately, I won’t be coming back here.”

65 Main St, West Sayville, NY 11796, United States

“We didn't order anything to eat. I ordered a mama tried cocktail suggested by the bartender and it was really good, it was smooth, sweet and fruty.”

1429 New York Ave, Huntington Station, NY 11746, United States

“I love this place. The food is amazing and they are very clean. The guys who work their are really good people too. Been coming here for years and no other tacos compare.”

297 Bay Shore Rd A, Deer Park, NY 11729, United States

“I ordered the Al pastor Mexico taco trio and a couple of beef tacos tonight 12/02/23. The food was delicious!!! The hot sauces both green and red.... delicious!! I ordered for take out and the order was ready quickly. The business is easily recognized as you drive up and passed. The place is clean and has a few tables for sitting down for a meal if you choose. I will certainly order from them again and I would recommend to anyone to give them a try! Well done 👏”

2 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United States

“Super cute spot in sag harbor. Right across the street from a really nice view of the water. This place is a bit pricey but seems like they serve quality everything. We didn’t order much but def got a taste for what they are doing. Almost $100 for one bottle water, three drinks, mushroom toast (1 slice of bread) and guacamole with chips. My dad got freshly squeezed orange juice. I got a classic marg which was so perfectly made but the amount of ice was an overkill. My sister got a shot that’s supposed to bring people back from the dead based on its name but tasted more like an espresso martini. The serving size was super tiny but I guess some people might consider it cute. These things took away from the value for me. The price we actually paid VS What we were actually served. The mushroom toast was actually delicious but again for the price, there is little value because it’s so tiny and hardly filling for anyone. The guacamole and chips were the best value and the guac was perfectly seasoned. Overall, I would consider going back to try their dinner menu which was what caught my eye when I initially discovered this place online. The neighborhood is super cute and worth checking out. Cute, simple and does the job but definitely can get expensive.”

464 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795, United States

“I drive 15 minutes out of my way in both directions to come here. The restaurant has a simple, but clean and friendly atmosphere. The staff is always friendly and the service is on point. I usually get the west islip lion burrito. Its got everything you wouldn't put in your every day burrito, but it hits the spot every time. I also get the meatless nachos which is loaded with toppings. Its almost impossible to get a nacho chip with nothing on it. Their empanadas are delicious as well. Just after writing this review, I noticed there was bacon in the burrito I ordered. I don't eat pork, so I called the restaurant to ask how to handle it since I don't live close. Not only did they make me a new one, but they drove all the way to my house 15 minutes away just to get my order and gave me a piece of tres leches cake. I've never had tres leches cake I've liked, but this cake is delicious. You guys are awesome. Thank you”

872 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, NY 11747, United States

“What we do like is their nachos, as you can see they are enormous. They have a happy hour so it’s nice to get some drinks and split a huge nachos. I have tried the wings and they were very good. The tacos were so so when I tried them close to when they first opened, but maybe I’ll give them another chance. They have an outdoor seating area on the side when the weather is nice, and there is a big parking lot all around the building.”

364 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

“Great place for food and drinks and views of the water were spectacular. Great for boat lovers too as it is located at the marina. Tacos, nachos, beers, and margarita’s are a must. Outdoor and covered seating with an exceptional staff and bartenders. A must do if you’re in Montauk.”